Medisafe vs MyTherapy vs Pillko: honest comparison for people choosing a pill tracker

If you are comparing Medisafe, MyTherapy, and Pillko, you are probably trying to figure out which one will actually help you remember your medications without getting in the way. All three are pill trackers. They take different approaches, and those differences matter depending on what you need.

Here is a direct comparison across the factors that actually affect daily use.

Medisafe

Strengths: Medisafe is the most established player. It has a large user base, a polished interface, and features like drug interaction warnings and a caregiver mode. If you want a feature-rich tracker with a proven track record, Medisafe delivers.

Weaknesses: Medisafe went paid in early 2026. The free tier now limits you to a small number of medications. If you manage multiple prescriptions, you will hit the paywall quickly. The app also requires an account, which means your medication data lives on their servers. For some users, that is a privacy concern.

Best for: People who want a full-featured tracker and do not mind paying for it.

MyTherapy

Strengths: MyTherapy has positioned itself as a free alternative to Medisafe. It offers unlimited medications on the free tier, which is a genuine advantage if you manage a complex regimen. The interface is clean, and the app includes a health journal feature.

Weaknesses: MyTherapy makes money through anonymized health data insights. If you are uncomfortable with your usage data being used for research, this is worth knowing. The app also shows ads in the free version, which can be distracting during the logging flow.

Best for: People managing multiple medications who want a free tier that does not limit their regimen.

Pillko

Strengths: Pillko takes a different approach. No account is required. No ads in the logging flow. Data stays on your device. The free version covers up to six medications. Paid unlocks unlimited. The interface is built around one-tap logging, so taking five seconds to record a dose actually takes five seconds.

Weaknesses: Pillko does not have the depth of features that Medisafe offers. No drug interaction warnings. No caregiver sharing. No health journal. If you need those features, Pillko will feel too simple.

Best for: People who want a private, no-fuss tracker that gets out of the way.

Side-by-side

Which should you choose

If you want the most features and do not mind paying: Medisafe.

If you manage many medications and want a free tier with no hard limits: MyTherapy.

If you want a private, ad-free, no-account tracker that handles the basics well: Pillko.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a free pill tracker that does not limit medications?

MyTheracy offers unlimited medications on its free tier. Pillko covers up to six on the free tier, which is enough for many users. Medisafe's free tier limits you to a small number.

Which pill tracker is most private?

Pillko keeps all data on your device and does not require an account. If privacy is your top priority, it is the strongest option.

Can I switch from Medisafe to another tracker easily?

Yes. Exporting your medication list from Medisafe and importing it into another tracker takes a few minutes. Most trackers, including Pillko, let you enter medications manually if needed.

Do I need drug interaction warnings?

If you are managing multiple prescriptions with overlapping conditions, yes. Medisafe is the strongest option for this. If you are tracking vitamins and a small number of prescriptions, the warnings may be less critical.

Try Pillko

Pillko is a free iPhone app with no ads, no account required, and no cloud upload. The free version covers up to six medications with one-tap logging and refill warnings.

Download Pillko on the App Store

---

Published: August 14, 2026 Category: App Comparison / Selection